Friday, January 21, 2022

Burton: Opinion: Canada approaches a watershed moment about who we really are

 Opinion: Canada approaches a watershed moment about who we really are

https://calgaryherald.com/opinion/columnists/opinion-canada-approaches-a-watershed-moment-about-who-we-really-are


https://youtu.be/283gmYtQw9I

For Canadians, the pandemic’s demise should mean not a return to yesterday’s normal, but a time to demand leadership that reboots our country with a renewed identity and purpose shaped by the values that make Canada a just, democratic society.

A meaningful, modern definition of Canada will also end the smug domination of national priorities by a “Laurentian elite” comprised mainly of white people with roots in the pasts of Ontario and Quebec. 

We must spend the money and do whatever is required politically to achieve just resolution of land claims; settle disputes over other treaty obligations; fulfil guarantees of such basic rights as clean water; provide legitimate social services, including health care and education; and support sustaining Indigenous languages. Achieving this and ending poverty and degradation within a conscionable time frame will require a resolve that circumvents exploitative lawyers and consultants who thrive on interminable legislative procedure.

An inescapable priority is funding the military to defend sovereignty in the Arctic, including its economically critical natural resources. Ottawa’s chronic dithering on this makes us easy prey in China’s march toward repressive superpower dominance, just as we fret but do little while China interferes in our electoral process, or menaces people in Canada who Beijing sees as threatening to its interests. It’s time to get our act together.

Wednesday, December 08, 2021

Burton: Ahead of a U.S. summit, China tries to move the goalposts on the meaning of ‘democracy’

Ahead of a U.S. summit, China tries to move the goalposts on the meaning of ‘democracy’ 

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-ahead-of-a-us-summit-china-tries-to-move-the-goalposts-on-the-meaning/


In the lead-up to the summit, China’s propaganda machine went into overdrive. On Saturday, its State Council issued a white paper entitled, China: Democracy That Works, which serves as China’s latest notice of global dominance. “China proposes to build a global community of shared future,” it reads, “and presses for a new model of international relations.”

While touting its own peculiar “democracy,” China neglects to mention that democracies are actually based on the principle of equal citizenship of all peoples. Whether it is tennis star Peng Shuai demanding that a retired Politburo member be held accountable for sexual assault allegations, or Uyghurs, Tibetans and Chinese Christians having the right to practise their religion in the language and culture of their tradition, or people being able to freely speak their thoughts on matters of politics and society without fear of arrest, democracy is the universal entitlement to civil freedoms, the inherent right to be ourselves and freely pursue our own future.

Friday, August 06, 2021

BURTON: What a potential cold war with China means for Canada

BURTON: What a potential cold war with China means for Canada 

https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/burton-what-a-potential-cold-war-with-china-means-for-canada


"Canada needs to stand with our liberal democratic allies in defence of the rules-based international order. The days of the federal government virtue signalling to dampen down the public opprobrium over China’s malign schemes, while Canada’s political and business elite pursue a self-interested policy of appeasement towards China, will have to end. Maintaining the pretense that the best China policy for Canada is one that steers a sophisticated diplomatic middle course between the U.S. and China is no longer viable.

Canada’s esoteric foreign policy doctrine of strategic deception wrongly assumes that what the country lacks in power and influence can be made up by cleverness. But it is simply an expression of Canadian naivety and greed."


Wednesday, July 21, 2021

Burton: Canada looks on as Biden rallies other allies to counter China

 Burton: Canada looks on as Biden rallies other allies to counter China

https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/2021/07/21/canada-looks-on-as-biden-rallies-other-allies-to-counter-china.html


"Our government’s increasingly pointed rhetoric with no substantive followup only confirms the weakness of Canada’s position with China, while Ottawa’s attempts at clever diplomacy in trying to steer a middle path between the PRC and the U.S. has only debased Washington’s faith in Canada’s commitment to the integrity of the international rules-based order.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau needs to phone President Biden to assure him of Canada’s support for positive determinations that come out of the QUAD meeting. Then we should not just talk the talk but stand up and show some courage of our convictions."

Friday, July 02, 2021

Burton and Chen Opinion: It’s a bad sign when elites are adopting Chinese Communist Party rhetoric

 Opinion: It’s a bad sign when elites are adopting Chinese Communist Party rhetoric

Some in the commentator class have forgotten the hard lessons about dealing with China

Charles Burton and Duanjie Chen

https://thehub.ca/2021-07-02/opinion-its-a-bad-sign-when-elites-are-adopting-chinese-communist-party-rhetoric/

"The authors ignore the fact that many of the regime’s most passionate critics are themselves of Chinese descent. They neglect to mention that the principal oppressor of the Chinese people is in fact the CCP itself. Calling this out is not racist; it is empowering to those who live in China and risk imprisonment for merely expressing opinions that the regime finds distasteful.

Worse still, this article from Evans and Woo is hardly an isolated statement from the authors; it certainly is not out of character. Most recently, Woo doubled down on repeating the rhetoric used by the wolf warriors in China’s Embassy in Ottawa, arguing that Canada cannot be critical of China’s ongoing genocide in Xinjiang due to Canada’s own deeply problematic history with residential schools.

This classic whataboutism is obviously not concerned about racial inequality or the wellbeing of Indigenous peoples, but again, defending the PRC regime against criticism for its abhorrent human rights abuses. The fact of Canada’s appalling history of gross mistreatment of indigenous peoples makes us Canadians even more sensitized to the evil of crimes against humanity being committed by autocratic racist regimes in China and elsewhere in the world. Woo has it exactly backwards."



Monday, May 17, 2021

Burton: Time for transparency in China's dealings with Canadian universities

 Opinion: Time for transparency in China's dealings with Canadian universities

It is reassuring that Alberta government officials have promised to protect Canada’s national interest by curtailing U of A collaborations with China in strategically sensitive science and technology, but will Ottawa initiate federal legislation such as requiring transparency in reporting of foreign sources of income? There is a powerful pro-PRC lobby in Ottawa, mostly retired politicians who are on China-related boards, including Canadian companies and law firms that benefit from the PRC. In taking China’s money, they are expected to support the interests of the PRC in Canada in return.

Beijing seems confident that, once Canadian public outrage fades over the latest reports of China’s shameless flouting of the norms of international relations, the Canadians on the PRC gravy train will resume quietly lobbying for Ottawa’s restraint in any new measures. This United Front work is a sophisticated engagement of Canada, and the PRC always seems to end up on top.

https://edmontonjournal.com/opinion/columnists/opinion-time-for-transparency-in-chinas-dealings-with-canadian-universities


Friday, March 19, 2021

Burton and Byers: COMMENTARY: Treatment of the Two Michaels reveals Canada’s lack of leverage in Beijing

 

COMMENTARY: Treatment of the Two Michaels reveals Canada’s lack of leverage in Beijing

https://globalnews.ca/news/7706849/michael-spavor-kovrig-china-trial/


But recent years have given stunning clarity to the true nature of the CCP regime. Petty, vindictive, arbitrary, and brutal, Beijing has made no mystery about its authoritarian intentions. Kovrig and Spavor’s plight fits a pattern of belligerence from the regime, including its military incursions and overt threat against its neighbours, genocide against Uyghurs in Xinjiang, blanket repression of cultural, racial, and religious minorities, militarization of international waters in the South China Sea, repression in Hong Kong, and so much more.

Canada’s naïveté toward China has left us impotent and rudderless in the face of Beijing’s aggression. What is desperately needed is for Ottawa to finally wake up to the reality that Canadians have acknowledged for some time: China is a clear threat that we must be prepared to stand against in concert with our allies.

Saturday, March 06, 2021

Burton: Canada needs a foreign agent registry to help it tackle China's influence

 Burton: Canada needs a foreign agent registry to help it tackle China's influence

https://ottawacitizen.com/opinion/burton-canada-needs-a-foreign-agent-registry-to-help-it-tackle-chinas-influence

Even though opinion polls indicate nearly nine in 10 Canadians want our government to be much more “proactive” in relations with China, the prime minister and cabinet are apparently listening to other voices, who may be rewarded by the PRC régime, saying we should be “sophisticated and mature” in our relations with China, abiding by China’s urging that we “set  aside differences and seek common ground.”

This latest statement by MP Oliphant, that the government is “actively considering” creating a registry of foreign agents, follows a familiar pattern. To appease or distract public opinion, the Trudeau government dangles a series of hollow promises, then just kicks the can down the road.

Canadians should demand that their government stop with the lip service and follow through with this now. As the old Lerner and Loewe show tune puts it “Sing me no song, read me no rhyme, please don’t explain. Show me!”



Tuesday, March 02, 2021

Canada’s Way Forward With Taiwan: Charles Burton For Inside Policy

 Canada’s Way Forward With Taiwan: Charles Burton For Inside Policy

https://www.macdonaldlaurier.ca/canadas-way-forward-taiwan/

"But today, with the re-election of President Tsai Ing-wen, the notion that the government of Taiwan does not deserve to be recognized as a legitimate government no longer holds. The awkward reality today is that Taiwan’s indisputably free and fair election makes clear that the current Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) government is the legitimate representation of the aspirations of the people of Taiwan.

Another factor is Canada's now dashed high hopes and aspirations for relations with the People's Republic of China, particularly since Xi Jinping came to power in 2012. While Canada and the PRC still maintain the framework of strategic partnership agreed to when the CCP Party General Secretary visited Canada in 2005, this partnership is no longer active. Simply put, the agreed to government-to-government consultations and programs of collaboration have gone into abeyance. What Canada and our like-minded democratic allies have today is very much a relationship of strategic adversary.

We need to recognize that the current government of democratic Taiwan is a legitimate regime that has effective sovereign control of its territory. As such, Canada’s desire to respect the feelings of the PRC by shunning Taiwan in global affairs is not longer relevant. It follows that Canada no longer has to adopt a Taiwan policy informed by appeasement to the PRC."




Thursday, December 10, 2020

Charles Burton: Kovrig and Spavor’s two-year ordeal and what it means for Canada-China relations

Charles Burton: Kovrig and Spavor’s two-year ordeal and what it means for Canada-China relations 

https://vancouversun.com/opinion/op-ed/charles-burton-kovrig-and-spavors-two-year-ordeal-and-what-it-means-for-canada-china-relations


Ignorant hubris of CCP's ignoble leaders makes them culpable for deep suffering of these innocent Canadians. But Ottawa has also mismanaged the situation due to its own misconceptions.

Tohti and Burton: Canada must respond to China's harrowing genocide

 Tohti and Burton: Canada must respond to China's harrowing genocide

by Mehmet Tohti and Charles Burton

If the international community does not condemn China’s campaign against Muslim minorities in Xinjiang province, a precedent will be set and such atrocities will be adopted by other regimes.

https://ottawacitizen.com/opinion/tohti-and-burton-canada-must-respond-to-chinas-harrowing-genocide

Friday, December 04, 2020

Burton: Joe Biden is coming – and Beijing should be worried

Joe Biden is coming – and Beijing should be worried 

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-joe-biden-is-coming-and-beijing-should-be-worried/

"But this is really about China’s worry that its hubristic global expansionist plans – a key element in the Chinese Communist Party’s legitimating ideology – are about to be seriously derailed. In contrast to President Donald Trump’s claim that Chinese President Xi Jinping is “terrific” and a “very special person,” the president-elect recently called Mr. Xi “a thug,” a global disruptor “who doesn’t have a democratic bone in his body.” Moreover, Mr. Biden has vowed to host a “global Summit for Democracy” next year, to bring together the world’s democracies and “strengthen our democratic institutions, honestly confront nations that are backsliding, and forge a common agenda.”

The Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China has urged that, this December, supporters of democracy around the world buy a bottle of Australian wine to show support for Australia against Chinese economic coercion. Evidently, the Australian reds are particularly good. This holiday season, let’s drink to that – and to a tougher, changing horizon for Beijing."

Thursday, November 26, 2020

Charles Burton: What a Biden Presidency means for Canada-Chinese Relations

 

  • Charles Burton: What a Biden Presidency means for Canada-Chinese Relations



It is hard to know how Biden will manage China. He has said that he regards Xi Jinping as “a thug”. He also has identified the Chinese policy towards the Turkic Muslims in Xinjiang as a genocide. He hopes to lead an international campaign to pressure, isolate, and punish China. So, from that point of view, his stance on China is much more aggressive than the Canadian government’s. The issue is whether or not Biden will carry on the general orientation of the Trump administration under current Secretary of State, Mike Pompeo with regard to how the U.S would stand for the international rules based order, which includes, respect for freedom, democracy, rights, and entitlements of citizens in those areas.

If Biden decides to negotiate a grand bargain with China that would include concerns that weren’t central to the Trump administration, such as climate change, nuclear non-proliferation, particularly relations with North Korea, and other issues like global health, then he might be prepared to make concessions to the Chinese

Friday, November 20, 2020

Burton: Canada should manage our China policy more honestly (opinion piece in Ottawa Citizen)

Burton: Canada should manage our China policy more honestly 


https://ottawacitizen.com/opinion/burton-canada-should-manage-our-china-policy-more-honestly

The argument that “ghosting” might obtain the release of Michaels Kovrig and Spavor, or avoid further economic retaliation that punishes Canadian business and farmers, has proven wrong-headed. After 711 days, two exemplary Canadian citizens are still in prison hell in the People’s Republic of China, neither of them deserving such vulgar abuse as Beijing tries to force Canada to comply with China’s political demands. Beijing obviously does not reward passivity with gestures of goodwill, and if the federal government continues to give in to the PRC’s amoral “wolf warrior diplomacy,” expect China to be thus emboldened to demand that Canada offer successive concessions in years ahead.


Monday, November 16, 2020

Burton: Canada takes note as China gets tough with Australia

Canada takes note as China gets tough with Australia

https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/2020/11/12/canada-takes-note-as-china-gets-tough-with-australia.html

Those who have urged that we treat the panda kindly, lest he show his claws and draw blood with his fangs, will urge that Canada continue ignoring the strong recommendations of Commons committees to support endangered Hong Kong democracy activists or to sanction Chinese officials complicit in the Uighur genocide. That perspective implies it would be best that Canada simply risk our alliance with the U.S. by releasing Meng Wanzhou, approving Huawei 5G and continue to allow PRC acquisition of Canadian dual-use technologies.

While Australia has strongly supported Canada over Kovrig and Spavor, it is unlikely that Ottawa will dare to stand with Australia in the face of Chinese bullying, beyond our usual carefully worded “expression of concern.” But Australia’s relations with China today are almost certainly Canada’s tomorrow. As the RUSI report notes, citing the ex-Australian PM and China scholar Kevin Rudd, “the Chinese Communist Party despises and takes advantage of weakness, while it respects strength.”



Saturday, October 24, 2020

Burton - "China: History as Destiny"

 China: History as Destiny

By Charles Burton,
Senior Fellow, the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Ottawa

As published by The Dorchester Review, Spring/Summer, 2020

https://williamgairdner.ca/some-deep-insight-on-china/


Thursday, October 22, 2020

Burton: As China’s global actions worsen, Canada looks at its feet

 Burton: As China’s global actions worsen, Canada looks at its feet

https://ottawacitizen.com/opinion/burton-as-chinas-global-actions-worsen-canada-looks-at-its-feet


Threats to the safety of Canadians by any other nation’s ambassador would have them turfed within 48 hours. Cong was instead called in to Global Affairs Canada for a chat requesting that he play nicer in future.

Of course, the People’s Republic of China would expel Canadian Ambassador Dominic Barton in retaliation, but that might not be such a bad thing. The Chinese evidently see him as a pushover, and don’t return his calls. While Ambassador Cong is all over the Canadian media with interviews and webinars, our man in Beijing is a non-person.

Tuesday, September 08, 2020

Opinion Piece in the Toronto Star "Burton: China threatens and intimidates people within Canada as Ottawa remains silent"

 China threatens and intimidates people within Canada as Ottawa remains silent

https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/2020/09/08/china-threatens-and-intimidates-people-within-canada-as-ottawa-remains-silent.html

What of the sotto voce reservations expressed about the impact of Canada doing anything that China would not like on the fate of hostages Michael Spavor and Michael Kovrig? After more than 600 days of incarceration, Ottawa’s refrain “we are working very hard” to achieve their release has worn thin. The fact is, Beijing will hold these two innocent men for as long as it benefits the furtherance of China’s agenda in Canada, regardless of any impact on China’s global credibility.

Currently, Beijing has got us where they want us. The tragic fallacy of Canada’s silence is that the longer we remain passive in the face of China’s appalling violations of international trade, diplomacy and human rights, the longer we can expect Kovrig and Spavor to remain in Chinese prison hell.

Thursday, August 06, 2020

Burton Opinion Piece in Globe and Mail: "America shouldn’t go it alone in containing China"

America shouldn’t go it alone in containing China 

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-america-shouldnt-go-it-alone-in-containing-china/

With little change in China’s recent behaviour, Western policies of appeasement have now been discredited. This presents an opportunity for the U.S. to assert, once and for all, that it is not a declining power. Yet, as Washington reshapes its engagement with China, it needs to start including middle powers in the negotiations. Limiting the engagement to bilateral fora between the U.S. and China has inadvertently given Beijing free rein to exploit power imbalances with smaller countries, weakening the global network of alliances and institutions meant to uphold democracy, justice and peace.